for information about this site's accessibility, click here
phoenix.gov. Image displaying City of Phoenix logo. Click to return home.
Downtown Phoenix skyline looking west at dusk

GO button. Click or press key to go to selection.

skip repetitive navigation
Discover Phoenix
Residents
Businesses
City Government
Employment
Youth & Seniors
e-Services
Home

NOTICE OF RESULTS
ZONING ADJUSTMENT HEARING

 

Pursuant to A.R.S. Section 38-431.02, notice is hereby given the ZONING ADJUSTMENT HEARING OFFICER and to the general public, that the CITY OF PHOENIX ZONING ADJUSTMENT HEARING OFFICER held a hearing open to the public on July 17, 2008, at 10:00 a.m. located in Assembly Room C, Phoenix City Hall, 200 West Washington Street, 1st Floor, Phoenix, Arizona.

 

The results of the hearing were as follows:

 

RESULTS

 

 

 

 

 

10:00 a.m.

 

Approved/ Stip

1.

Application #:

ZA-368-08-6

 

Existing Zoning:

RE-35 ACSPD

 

Location:

4931 East White Gates Drive

 

Block Location:

4900 E. – 5200 N.

 

Quarter Section:

19-39

 

Proposal:

Variance to increase the square footage of a guesthouse to 1,105 square feet. Maximum size allowed 900 square feet.

 

Ordinance Sections:

609.C.2.

 

Applicant:

Phillip A. McCreary

 

Representative:

Phillip A. McCreary

 

Owner:

Phillip A. McCreary

 

STIPULATION:

1)    Per the site plan submitted, signed and dated July 17, 2008.

 

 

 

 

Approved

2.

Application #:

ZA-369-08-6

 

Existing Zoning:

C-2

 

Location:

4126 East Indian School Road

 

Block Location:

4100 E. – 4100 N.

 

Quarter Section:

17-37

 

Proposal:

1) Use permit to operate a pet care facility. Use permit required. 2) Variance to locate a building or exercise run within 100 feet of a lot line abutting a residential district. Variance required.

 

Ordinance Sections:

623.D.130.1. 623.D.130.1.d.

 

Applicant:

Adam Baugh, Withey Morris

 

Representative:

Adam Baugh, Withey Morris

 

Owner:

Jackie Brenda, DogMo

 

 

 

 

Denied

3.

Application #:

ZA-372-08-4

 

Existing Zoning:

C-2

 

Location:

3816 North 7th Street

 

Block Location:

3800 N. – 700 E.

 

Quarter Section:

16-28

 

Proposal:

Variance to reduce the number of required parking spaces to 69. 92 parking spaces required.

 

Ordinance Sections:

702.A.3.Table

 

Applicant:

Alexander Jacinto/Robert Kubicek Architect

 

Representative:

Alexander Jacinto/Robert Kubicek Architect

 

Owner:

Jim Rockwell

 

 

 

 

Approved/ Stip

4.

Application #:

ZA-373-08-5

 

Existing Zoning:

CP/BP

 

Location:

2235 West Alice Avenue

 

Block Location:

2200 W. – 8750 N.

 

Quarter Section:

26-24

 

Proposal:

Variance to allow a 6-foot fence 17 feet from the west property line. Maximum height allowed 40 inches for the perimeter boundary (southwest portion).

 

Ordinance Sections:

703.A.3.a.

 

Applicant:

Gary McMillion

 

Representative:

Gary McMillion

 

Owner:

Jewish Voice Ministries

 

STIPULATION:

1)    The proposed wrought iron fence shall be located immediately adjacent to the existing curb of the driveway, approximately 17 to 18 feet behind the property line.

 

 

 

 

Approved

5.

Application #:

ZA-377-08-1

 

Existing Zoning:

CP/BP

 

Location:

22225 North 29th Avenue, #201

 

Block Location:

22000 N. – 2900 W.

 

Quarter Section:

43-22

 

Proposal:

Variance to reduce the street side setback for an interior lot line on a street to 12 feet. Minimum 30 feet required.

 

Ordinance Sections:

626.H.Table

 

Applicant:

Jason G. Miller

 

Representative:

Jason G. Miller

 

Owner:

Local Union 387 Electrical Workers Build

 

 

 

 

Approved/ Stips

6.

Application #:

ZA-378-08-6

 

Existing Zoning:

R1-10

 

Location:

7229 North 11th Avenue

 

Block Location:

7200 N. – 1100 W.

 

Quarter Section:

23-26

 

Proposal:

Variance to reduce side setback to 0 feet. Minimum 10 feet required.

 

Ordinance Sections:

609.B Table

 

Applicant:

John Gregg

 

Representative:

Antonio Desilva

 

Owner:

John Gregg

 

STIPULATIONS:

1)    For the conversion of the carport into a garage on the south side of the property (along Northview Avenue).

2)    Encroachment into the right-of-way shall be given permission by the Streets Department or have the fascia removed back to property line.

 

 

 

 

 

 

1:30 p.m.

 

Continued

7.

Application #:

ZA-217-08-8 – (Sign)

 

Existing Zoning:

A-1

 

Location:

2113 East Sky Harbor Circle

 

Block Location:

2100 E. – 1600 S.

 

Quarter Section:

8-32

 

Proposal:

1) Variance to allow an outdoor advertising structure within a redevelopment area designated by the City of Phoenix. Variance required. 2) Variance to allow an outdoor advertising structure on the inner loop of the I-10. Outdoor advertising structures shall be located within 300 of the mainline of I-10 from the end of I-17 to the eastern City limits. Variance required.

 

Ordinance Sections:

705.2.A.7.d. 705.2.A.15.

 

Applicant:

CBS Outdoor

 

Representative:

Martin Aronson/Morrill & Aronson, PLC

 

Owner:

Gannon Arizona Realty, LLC

 

CONTINUED TO AUGUST 21, 2008 AT 3:30 P.M. WITH FEE.

 

 

 

 

Approved

8.

Application #:

ZA-367-08-6

 

Existing Zoning:

R1-6

 

Location:

1111 East Stella Lane

 

Block Location:

1100 E. – 6400 N.

 

Quarter Section:

21-29

 

Proposal:

Variance to increase lot coverage to 48.6%. 40% maximum allowed.

 

Ordinance Sections:

613.B.Table B

 

Applicant:

Jose Avila

 

Representative:

Jose Avila

 

Owner:

Jose Avila

 

 

 

 

Continued

9.

Application #:

ZA-375-08-8

 

Existing Zoning:

DC

 

Location:

30 North 1st Street

 

Block Location:

30 N. – 100 E.

 

Quarter Section:

10-28

 

Proposal:

1) Variance to reduce the required setback for the 1st floor to 16 feet. Minimum 20 feet required. 2) Variance to reduce the required setback for the 2nd floor to 0 feet. Minimum 20 feet required. 3) Variance to reduce the required arcade width to 8 feet. Minimum 12 feet required. 4) Variance to delete the requirement that street tree improvements shall be made. Street tree improvements required. 5) Variance to reduce the required parking space width to 9 feet. 9 feet, 6 inches required. 6) Variance to delete the requirement for an off-street loading bay. 1 off-street loading bay required.

 

 

Ordinance Sections:

643.E.2.b.(1) 643.E.2.b.(1) 643.J.5.a. 643.J.5.c. 702.A.2.b.(2).A. 643.F.1.b.

 

Applicant:

Jon Hanna/Whitneyball Perry Inc.

 

Representative:

Jon Hanna/Whitneyball Perry Inc.

 

Owner:

David J Mackenzie/Copperpoint Development

 

CONTINUED TO JULY 24, 2008 AT 3:30 P.M. WITH FEE.

 

 

 

 

Approved/ Stips

10.

Application #:

ZA-382-08-3

 

Existing Zoning:

C-2

 

Location:

9832 North 7th Street

 

Block Location:

9800 N. – 700 E.

 

Quarter Section:

28-28

 

Proposal:

Use permit to allow outdoor dining as an accessory use to a restaurant (Scramble). Use permit required.

 

Ordinance Sections:

623.D.152.c.

 

Applicant:

Dennis Alexander & Don Talbot - Scramble

 

Representative:

Tony DeFabritis - D.T. Design

 

Owner:

Robert Ferdinad

 

STIPULATIONS:

1)    Per plan submitted, signed and dated July 17, 2008.

2)    Hours of operation from 6:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m., 7 days a week.

 

 

 

 

 

 

2:30 p.m.

 

Denied

11.

Application #:

ZA-371-08-4

 

Existing Zoning:

R1-6

 

Location:

4322 West Monterey Way

 

Block Location:

4300 W. – 3250 N.

 

Quarter Section:

15-18

 

Proposal:

Variance to reduce the front yard (Monterey Way) setback to 11 feet. 20 feet required.

 

Ordinance Sections:

613.B. Table B

 

Applicant:

Thelma Nazionale

 

Representative:

Thelma Nazionale

 

Owner:

David & Thelma Nazionale

 

 

 

 

Approved/ Stip

12.

Application #:

ZA-376-08-6

 

Existing Zoning:

C-1

 

Location:

5002 East Warner Road

 

Block Location:

5000 E. – 12400 S.

 

Quarter Section:

07-39

 

Proposal:

Variance to allow an over height fence (60 feet). Maximum 6 feet required.

 

Ordinance Sections:

703.A.1.a.

 

Applicant:

Brian Schroder, Apex Custom Homes

 

Representative:

Silvio Vaninetti, Phoenix Fire Department

 

Owner:

City of Phoenix (Fire Station #38)

 

STIPULATION:

1)    Per the site plan submitted, signed and dated July 17, 2008.

 

 

 

 

Withdrawn

13.

Application #:

ZA-379-08-2

 

Existing Zoning:

RE-24

 

Location:

6740 East Voltaire Avenue

 

Block Location:

6700 E. – 13700 N.

 

Quarter Section:

32-43

 

Proposal:

1) Variance to increase the lot coverage to 36%. Maximum lot coverage 25% required. 2) Variance to allow an over height fence (7 feet, 8 inches) in the front yard. Maximum 40-inch fence allowed.

 

Ordinance Sections:

606.B.5. 703.A.2.a.

 

Applicant:

Richard McDonald

 

Representative:

Bill Dougherty/Citywide Builders

 

Owner:

Richard McDonald

 

 

 

 

Continued

14.

Application #:

ZA-381-08-3

 

Existing Zoning:

R1-6

 

Location:

13041 North 18th Place

 

Block Location:

13000 N. – 1800 E.

 

Quarter Section:

32-31

 

Proposal:

1) Variance to increase the lot coverage to 47%. Maximum 40% allowed. 2) Variance to reduce the side yard setback (south) to 7 feet. Minimum 10 feet required.

 

Ordinance Sections:

613.B.Table B 613.B. Table B

 

Applicant:

Albert & Lynn Reach

 

Representative:

Marlyn E. Reamy

 

Owner:

Albert & Lynn Reach

 

CONTINUED TO SEPTEMBER 4, 2008 AT 3:30 P.M. WITH FEE.

 

 

 

 

 

 

3:30 p.m.

 

Approved/ Stip

15.

Application #:

ZA-298-08-2 – (Sign) (Continued from June 5, 2008)

 

Existing Zoning:

S-1

 

Location:

32648 North Cave Creek Road

 

Block Location:

32600 N. – 4000 E.

 

Quarter Section:

56-39

 

Proposal:

Variance to allow wall signs for a non-residential use in a residential district to be placed at 19 feet high where 15 feet is the maximum allowed. Variance required.

 

Ordinance Sections:

705.D. Table D-1

 

Applicant:

Denny Collins/Precise Signs

 

Representative:

Denny Collins/Precise Signs

 

Owner:

St. Gabriel's Catholic Church

 

STIPULATIONS:

1)    If trees are trimmed significantly enough to cause death the tree will be replaced with the same type of tree, as approved by the Development Services Department.

 

 

 

 

Approved

16.

Application #:

ZA-104-07-7 – (1-Year Review) (Continued from March 6, 2008)

 

Existing Zoning:

App. C-2 PCD

 

Location:

8301 West Encanto Boulevard

 

Block Location:

8300 W. – 2300 N.

 

Quarter Section:

13-8

 

Proposal:

Use permit to allow an open car wash in a C-2 district. Use permit required.

 

Ordinance Sections:

623.D.39.

 

Applicant:

Michael Scarbrough/Quick N Clean

 

Representative:

Michael Scarbrough/Quick N Clean

 

Owner:

Adrian Evarkiou/Orsett Properties, LTD

 

 

 

 

Approved/ Stip

17.

Application #:

ZA-544-05-4 – (30-Month Review) (Continued from May 29, 2008)

 

Existing Zoning:

C-2

 

Location:

5201 North Central Avenue

 

Block Location:

5200 N. – 0

 

Quarter Section:

19-28

 

Proposal:

Variance to allow an over height fence of 6 feet in the required front. Maximum height of 3 feet allowed.

 

Ordinance Sections:

703.A.2.(a)

 

Applicant:

Geno Mammini, Miller Brooks Environmental

 

Representative:

Britt Callahan, Miller Brooks Environmental

 

Owner:

Mike Beasley, Shell Oil Products US

 

STIPULATION:

1)    Fence can continue to remain at site until environmental remediation is complete.

 

 

ZONING ADJUSTMENT HEARING OFFICER WAS: FRANK DOLASINSKI

PLANNER WAS: CRAIG MAVIS

 

 

For further information, please call Ed Keyser, Planner II, Planning Department at 602-495-0382, or contact via electronic mail at zoning@phoenix.gov.  This electronic mail address will not accommodate zoning enforcement/violation complaints.

 

For reasonable accommodations, call Theresa Damiani at Voice/602-262-6368 or the City TTY/

602-534-5500 as early as possible to coordinate needed arrangements.

 

 

S:\Zoning Adjustments\Hearings\ZA\Marked Agenda\2008 Marked Agendas\071708 ma.doc

|  phoenix.gov en espaρol   |  Back   |  Contact Us   |  Accessibility   |  Privacy Policy   |  Security   |  Help   |
© Copyright 2008, City of Phoenix

Last Modified on 08/29/2008 14:26:58